Tag: Amul

  • Bounceback in TV Ad Rev… but 19.3% drop

     

    By Shripad Kulkarni

     

    Why and how TV was decoded

    Coming on the back of the India adspends degrowth in 2019 second half, the pandemic dealt a big blow to advertising. Undoubtedly, print bore the brunt of the C-19 impact, followed by Radio. Digital has had a field day, in terms of media consumption and e-commerce.

    Digital Spends too have got a good boost, but it will take some time to translate the digital consumption into a commensurate huge spike in paid media. On the other hand, at about 37% of Total Spends, Television is pretty much the mainstay. The massive rise in News Viewership saw a commensurate thrust on the News Genre from Advertisers.  In Aug-Oct, IPL led a bounceback to get the advertising on a much better wicket. Live Telecast of IPL, in many ways has helped in the kickstart of advertising during festive. So, decoding TV-led bounceback helps us understand many facets of Indian advertising. While we will look at the spends trend based on prevailing rates during the various pandemic phases, ad volumes help in a detailed understanding of the strategies deployed.

    However, care has to be taken to do a like-to-like comparison. So, IPL of 2019 to be compared with IPL 2020 (though it was in festive). And general entertainment/news separately for same period.

     


    Look out for an interview with the author and veteran mediaperson on Thursday, December 10.


     

    I have looked at Average Monthly Commercial Airtime by Key Channel Genres. We looked at the top-rated channels in each genre as a group, which contribute to 75-85% genre revenue. So, Genres detailed are: Top 4 Hin GEC1 channels, next 4 Hin GEC2, 6 Hin Mov, 6 Hin News, 4 E News, 12 Reg News, 5 Eng Mov,  and 15 Regional Channels of South, Marathi and Bengali. The Balance are grouped as Long Tail. 10 months of 2020 are compared with the corresponding period of 2018 and 2019.Till October 30, 50 IPL matches were completed, so IPL is compared with 50 matches of 2019

    Summary of the findings

    1. IPL – a grand marketing success

     

    IPL was a grand success, not just as an event, where BCCI showed exemplary guts and execution, but also of the Disney Star AdSales team. That’s because you have to pre-sell an event like IPL. And, at a 5% additional airtime in live, at a premium over last year is a fantastic performance which kick started the advertising rebound. I estimate IPL to have got a 12% Revenue increase over last year.

     

    2. The rebound was driven by E-com, BFSI and Healthcare

    IPL as well as News and General entertainment both were driven by these categories.
    It looks like the new economy will have to use offline media for the top of the funnel
    So, BFSI and the New economy brands will continue to be the drivers for next couple of years.

     

    3. Jan-Oct TV ad revenue shrunk by just 19%, due to the rebound

    As we know, in Apr-Jun 2020, there was a big drop in adspends. Listed companies Zee Entertainment, Sun TV and TV18 reported a whopping 60% average drop in revenue, while TV Today reported a 35% drop (over same period LY). By Jul-Sepm this drop was reduced to about 26% for the GEC Groups while TV Today bounced back to last year’s revenue level. Studying the average rate trends across the Pandemic phases of Apr-May, June-July and Aug-Oct, we estimate that the TV Spends, in fact have dropped by a significant 19% so far – which is a good rebound considering we were staring at a minimum 40% drop in ad revenue!

     

    4. Long tail of Advertisers has to wag for Advertising to grow

    Just 27 top advertisers contribute to 50% Commercial airtime and just under 500 Advertisers contribute to 90%. We have a long way to go to realise the potential of India. We need a significant no of advertisers from the long tail to move up and graduate to big advertisers. The process has started. Even in this period, over 1200 insignificant advertisers moved to being significant. This was largely, on the back of news and Hindi/regional channels.

    5. Long tail of Channel Genres will shrink

    Today the long tail contributes to a whopping 81% of Airtime and 23% revenue.

    The Revenue of the Long tail, however has dropped by 32%, with English dropping by over 50%

     

    6. Amul and Dabur have shown the Industry how to make the best of a crisis

    Both Amul and Dabur, our homegrown Master Brands went aggressively promoting many more brands than last two years and growing their commercial airtime by a whopping 125%.

     

     

     

     

  • Recording the Passing via Amul ads

     

    The Amul topical ads crafted by the team at da Cunha associates are in every way perhaps the best chronicler of our times. Here we have compiled the advertisements that Amul has published in 2020 on the various personalities who have passed away.

     

     

  • The Obsession To Be Premium

     

    By Avik Chattopadhyay

     

    The other day I was chatting up with a Maruti Suzuki Nexa dealer. Post the expected lament on lack of footfalls and the still elusive operating profit, we got into discussing the basic Nexa model – the purpose, the promise and the delivery. After a lot of soul-searching and head scratching, he finally brought it down to the wooden flooring, fancy furniture and focused lighting as the “premium” experience being offered to a customer vis-à-vis one who walked into a Maruti Suzuki Arena!

     

    Sounds preposterous? Totally believable!

    Let’s just spend a few more words on this Nexa vis-à-vis Arena case. The two channels of the same Maruti Suzuki brand offer separate products to customers, hence ensuring a minimum level of footfalls in both. I cannot buy an Ignis from an Arena outlet, hence go to a Nexa. Similarly, I cannot pick up a WagonR at a Nexa, hence go to an Arena. It is not that I have a similar product portfolio in both, yet I choose a Nexa over an Arena as the entire customer promise and experience is what I associate with and aspire for.

     

    There are various ways I can be premium in being a Nexa channel partner.

    In my product pricing. But the Nexa offers the Baleno that is in the same price band as the Swift.

    In my product positioning by addressing a different customer psychographic. But, then, the Ciaz was moved from Arena to Nexa to allow more revenues to the latter.

    In my overall experience. But the service and ownership experience, as per customer feedback and dealer inputs, are the same in Nexa and Arena.

     

    So, I am fundamentally undifferentiated from my less privileged channel cousin and totally confused in what I am supposed to be in the first place. Yet, I boast that I am “premium”. Not a very sustainable business model, is it?

     

    Maruti Suzuki’s urge to go premium is not an oddity. It is another demonstration of the common malaise many Indian brands have – the obsession to be premium!

     

    From aviation to automobiles, food to furniture, healthcare to homes, brands and businesses make proud statements in press releases and communication that they are a premium brand or aim to go premium.

     

    It is as if being entry-level or mass-market is a protozoan life rid of all respect and pride. It is as if being affordable is an affront to business logic and purpose.

     

    In the three decades I have spent working for a living, I have come across a handful of seniors and bosses who have also expressed this desire to ‘elevate’ the brand into a premium one. Basically, making the customer pay more money for the same product or solution. And how will that happen? Magical marketing! Spend on symbols of an elevated status like brand ambassadors, sponsorships and imagery to package the same product in a new avatar!

     

    Does this not work? It does, for some time and for some people. But it is never sustainable as the brand is desperately trying to live on borrowed clothes and makeup.

     

    Have I been successful in any such attempt? Not once. Have tried a few times but failed miserably. But in the process, have learnt five important lessons which I wish to share.

     

    Premium vis-à-vis Expensive

    These are two separate concepts. A Harley-Davidson is expensive. It is not premium. It is expensive because the Americans can just not get efficient enough. But in its home market no one buys it for its premium-ness but for its distinct imagery and culture code.

     

    Mass vis-à-vis Premium

    A Bic ballpen is mass. And people love it because it is so. But a special edition Bic commemorating the Black Lives Matter movement will certainly sell at a premium. Similarly, a Maruti Suzuki Swift is mass. But a 15th anniversary limited edition Swift Sport will be premium. Hence, mass and premium are not mutually exclusive concepts… in reality.

     

    Premium vis-à-vis VFM

    These are not conflicting at all. In fact, the better a brand is able to demonstrate value-for-money [VFM] to its target customer, the better the premium it will attract. And not extract. I once met Mr R M Dhariwal, the owner of the Manikchand Group, who told me that he bought a Maybach for his daughter on her birthday as believed for the amount of money he wanted to spend, the Maybach offered him best value for money!

     

    The intangible value of a product or experience, over and above the physical value is what allows a brand to command a premium. And not just demand it.

     

    Premium vis-à-vis Profit

    These two are not necessary and sufficient conditions to co-exist. There are mass-market brands that make profits that many luxury brands would give both arms for. A premium offering need not make higher profits than an entry-level one. The focussed definition and delivery of its promise is what makes a brand charge a premium.

     

    Response vis-à-vis Objective

    This is the biggest lesson for me. Being “premium” is a desired consumer response and not a business goal or objective. It is an outcome and not the process. It is the end and not the means. This clarity of brand management happens only when the brand stays true to its intended purpose and promise.

     

    We experience brands like Bata, Amul, McDonald’s and Chevrolet not because they are positioned as “premium” but because they are true to their brand DNA and carry no pretensions. As customers, we give them their due premiums when we wait for the pack of Amul Taaza milk to arrive at the store, love to see the sparkle in the eyes of our children on getting them a Happy Meal, squeal the hell out of the tyres of a gleaming Corvette or splash about in muddy puddles in the Naughty Boy shoes. Each of these experiences is what truly makes a brand “premium”!

     

     

  • Utterly, Butterly, Dhoni-licous!

     

    Former Indian cricket captain M S Dhoni starred in many Indian cricket milestones in recent years. As he announced his retirement on Saturday via Instagram, we play back the several Amul Butter topical ads crafted by the ace team at da Cunha. Let’s take a look

     

    You'll be missed!
    BCCI does not renew Dhoni’s contract! – (Jan’ 20)
    No byes for Dhoni?
    Intense speculation on the retirement plans of the former wicketkeeper-captain… – (Nov’ 19)
    Dhoni’s Ambatting superbly!
    MSD & Rayudu combine wonderfully for CSK! – (Apr’ 18)
    Hum Dhoni, Do Premi!
    Celebrating MSD’s return to form for Pune Rising Supergiant! – Apr’17
    DHONiNG A NEW ROLE!
    MSD steps down as ODI & T20 captain… (Jan, 17)
    Captain Not-So-Cool?
    Dhoni turns interviewer at press con!
    Biryanahin!
    Dhoni denied home-cooked food by hotel ! – Sept’14
    Late cut, square cut & hair cut!
    MS Dhoni’s new haircut – Sept.’13
    Yeh Kaisa Rhiti Revaaj hai?
    Controversy regarding Dhoni’s involvement in Rhiti sports – June’13
    No baat? No bol?
    Dhoni maintains silence over spot fixing issues . – May’13
    Kisko captain banana?
    Controversy over Dhoni continuing as Captain – Dec’12
    Rona Dhoni bandh Karo!
    Indian captain asks curators to ‘doctor’ pitches – Dec’12
    DHONI-TE- NAN!
    M.S.Dhoni scored a blistering 124 of 107 balls (9 fours, 3 sixes) in the second ODI against Australia. – Oct’09.
    Anhoni ko Dhoni karde !
    Team India celebrate after winning the inaugural ICC WORLD TWENTY 20, SOUTH AFRICA 2007 cricket World Cup in Johannesburg – September’ 07.
    Baalle baaz!
    On Mahendra Singh Dhoni for his contribution to India’s good performance – February ’06
  • Utterly Butterly Maha-licious

     

    Once again we lean on the Amul topicals to tell the story – on Sharad Pawar, the race for the CM post and on the Shiv Sena. We were a little surprised though that there haven’t been, but guess doing a funny ‘un on the Sena is a serious matter…

     

    This is when Sharad Pawar came back to the political arena in Maharashtra as Chief Minister (1986)

     

    Return of Sharad Pawar as Chief Minister of Maharashtra in 1986

     

    There was a furore when the Australian cricketers pushed the then BCCI President Sharad Pawar at ICC Champions Trophy prize distribution ceremony at in Mumbai in November  2006… the joke doing the rounds is that only Ricky Ponting & Co had the you-know-what to push Pawar!

     

    Amul reflects the Shiv Sena’s popularity in Mumbai. This was in 1989, when the city was still called Bombay.

     

    Politicians fighting for the CM’s post… may not have been done for Maharashtra, but we all know what’s been happening over the last few days

     

    Was a topical that appeared in October 2014

     

    Remember there was a problem in Maharashtra in September 2014 too…

     

    This was done when there was a change of CMs in Maharashtra in Jan 2003
  • Utterly Butterly Kohli-cious

    Virat, first batsman to 20K international runs in a single decade! – Aug’ 19

     

     

    India Kivictorious!
    Virat’s team on a roll! – (Jan’ 19)

     

    Virogershka!
    Virat & Anushka pose with Federer at the Aus Open!- (Jan’ 19)

     

    He’s Virat his weight in gold!
    Kohli second fastest to 25th test ton! – (Dec’ 18)

     

    Viratuoso performance!
    Kohli’s solo master class in batsmanship!- (Aug’ 18)

     

    Ball swing hoga ki balla?
    Keenly contested India-England series begins… as Virat Kohli takes on James Anderson. – (July’ 18)

     

    Kohli wax the ball!
    Virat’s statue now in Madame Tussaud’s Delhi museum! – (June’ 18)

     

    Sau many records for Virat!
    Kohli scores century after century as captain! (Nov’17)

     

    Virat’s Amessing achievement !
    Indian cricket captain has higher brand value than Argentinian football star! – (Oct’ 17)

     

    Virat's Kohling the shots?
    When will Indian cricket coach be announced?- July’17

     

    TRUMPED UP CHARGES AGAINST VIRAT!
    Aussie media compares Indian skipper to US President.- March’17

     

    India's most engaging couple!
    Anushka-Virat ..will they-won’t they? – Dec’16

     

    Team 1ndia!
    Virat Kohli receives ICC test championship mace!

     

    Kohlissal achievement!
    Virat’s incredible four IPL tons!

     

    When V are together !
    The AB/Virat ‘jugalbandi’ fires consistently for RCB!

     

    KOHLI KE PEECHE KAUN HAI?
    Super Virat’s single-handed success! – March’16

     

    KOHLi-PEEli ANUSHKA KO BLAME MAT KARO !
    Virat’s failure being linked to love life ! – Aug’14

     

    Kohli-peeli jaasti bhav mat kha!
    Virat Kohli abuses fans of Mumbai India

     

    Gaali Cricket!
    On field spat between Virat Kohli & Gautam Gambhir in IPL April’13

     

     

  • India-Pakistan Ratings: Busting the Fragmentation Myth

    The Amul ad on the India-Pakistan World Cup match

     

    By Shailesh Kapoor

     

    The ratings for the India-Pakistan World Cup cricket match on June 16 are out. The hopelessly-one-sided game scored a whopping 18+ TVR (Urban All India). Ratings nearing 20 can only evoke nostalgia for those following the Indian TV market over the years. It’s in the first half of the decade of 2000s that one would see such numbers for daily shows, with Kyunkii… and Kahaani… leading the way for a while. Thereafter, the numbers progressively dropped, a trend that’s generally believed to be an outcome of the launch of more channels and the resultant fragmentation of content choices available.

     

    The top Hindi GEC show moved from the 20-mark in early 2000s to the 10-mark late in that decade. In the first half of the decade starting 2010, the 5-6 level was aspiring enough. Today, even a 3-level is gold.

     

    Movie ratings have also shown a downward trend, but nowhere close to soaps. The top movie could do 15+ rating about 15 years ago, the equivalent of which is a 7-8 rating today. That’s a 50-60% drop, vis-à-vis an 80%+ more drop when you compare the top Hindi GEC shows across the same two periods.

     

    The popular belief has been that with the expansion of the measurement universe over the years, the true heterogeneity of the Indian market has a more and more significant impact on the TV ratings. That, combined with a multiplication in the number of channel options, would mean that fragmentation, and the resultant creation of a long tail, is inevitable.

     

    The India-Pakistan match ratings challenge this notion head on. The message from the audience is clear: If there’s content that carries a certain level of appeal and viewer pull, India can be fairly homogenous after all. Yes, there are more options and more diversity in the universe today. But there’s always content that cuts through, because it enjoys that broad-based appeal. And hence, justifying sub-3 numbers as the best-case scenario is only a self-fulfilling prophecy, whereby content creators and broadcasters are justifying low ratings as a market behaviour, than questioning them as symptoms of a loss in the collective ability of the industry to make truly mass, pan-India shows.

     

    One may argue that big-ticket sporting events have the ability that genres like drama, comedy and non-scripted content lack. That’s a fair argument too. But one is not expecting the top show to deliver 18-rating. Even the inert and one-sided India-South Africa match touched the 6-mark (averaged over more than seven hours, no less!). That’s surely a level a top Hindi GEC show should aspire to achieve. But today, even half of that is being celebrated as an outright success.

     

    If these signs continue, we may soon be a television market where sports, news and movies become the staple, and drama the alternative. It has already started happening during events like the IPL, the elections and now the World Cup. It could be a matter of time when more routine days begin to exhibit this trend too.

     

    If all the content creators can take a week’s break from their OTT pre-occupation and think about this, I’m sure they have the collective ability to come up with something worthy. The real question is: Do they have the will? Or has television already been reduced to a fuddy-duddy medium that’s not even cool to ideate about?

     

     

  • Utterly Butterly Yuvi-licious

     

    We bring you some iconic Amul topicals that have tracked the just-retired cricket star Yuvraj Singh. We are sure Amul will come up with a cool one on his retirement… meanwhile, don’t miss these….

     

    Yuvraj as Dulharaj!
    Six sixes. Saat pheras – Nov’16

     

    Auction Replay?
    Yuvraj fetches record price again in IPL bidding.-Feb’15

     

    Return of the Singh!
    Cricketers Yuvraj Singh and Harbhajan Singh back in action – Sept’12

     

    Yu and vi will fight this together!
    Wishing prominent Indian cricketer Yuvraj Singh a speedy recovery! – Feb’12

     

    Yuva Ka raj
    On Yuvraj and Kaif playing a stellar role in India’s cricket victory over England – July 2002.

     

    Rejyuvinate yourself!
    Indian cricketer’s outstanding performance in the current World Cup – Mar’ 2011

     

     

  • The World Cup 2015 Story via Amul Ads

     

    India didn’t go beyond the semi-finals in the 2015 edition of the World Cup. But even though we didn’t make it to the finals, it was a reasonably good showing. As the 2019 World Cup begins today (Thu, May 30), we bring you the story of the last World Cup via our fav Amul topical ads.

    Fifth World Cup in OZ’s pouch.-March’15
    WC ’15. You win some! You lose some!
    India in the last four!
    Sangakkara breaks WC century record! – March’15
    India head their pool in WC 2015.- March’15
    First cricketer to hit a World cup double ton! – Feb’15
    Indian batsmen welcome return to form ! – Feb’’15
    Much awaited World Cup Indo-Pak game! – Feb’15

     

  • Utterly Butterly Modi-licious

     

    There’s no better tracker of the mood of the country than the Amul topical ads. MxMIndia readers know how much we love them. As the general election results are set to be announced on Thursday, May 23, we track Narendra Modi’s journey as Prime Minister via Amul ads. Note we have not featured a few of the topicals on key developments of the last five years (like demonetisation and GST) as they do not feature the Prime Minister in the visuals.

     

    Modiji, Kuchch meetha ji!
    Hon PM inaugurates Amul’s Chocolate Plant at Anand – (Sep’ 18)

    Davoice of the PM!
    Prime Minister Modi addresses World Economic Forum! – (Jan’ 18)

    Modijeet!
    BJP wins Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh elections! – (Dec’ 17)

    USAfir hoon yaaron…
    Mr Modi meets Mr Trump! – (June’ 17)

    Modison Square Garden!
    P.M. enthralls audience in New York ! – Sept’14

    Bharatiya SAARCar!
    Modi’s swearing-in ceremony.- May’14

    AB KI BAR,BHAJAP SWEEKAR !
    Modi’s landslide victory!

    Uttar mein Chadhaav!
    BJP landslide win! – March’17

    KiSKA PATNA KATEGA?
    Upcoming crucial Bihar elections!-Aug’15

    Incredible for India
    Path breaking visit by PM! -July’17

    German dost, Spanish coast, Russian host, French toast!
    PM’s Europe tour!- May’17

    MAN KI BAAT !
    PM meets his predecessor

    Mongolyatra!
    PM’s historic visit –May’15

    And the highest coat is....
    Bidding for PM’s pinstriped suits soars ! – Feb’15

    Siachen jahan se achcha !
    PM’s Diwali celebrations with jawans ! -Oct’14

    Talkyo, Japan.
    PM’s visit to the Land of the Rising Sun –Sept’14

    Shalom Namaste!
    Israeli Prime Minister comes to India! – (Jan’ 18)

     

     

  • Avengers: The Marvelous India Story

    An Amul ad capturing the popularity of the latest Avengers release

     

    By Shailesh Kapoor

     

    Two weekends ago, Avengers: Endgame released in India as easily the most-anticipated Hollywood film ever. At a staggering 52 Cr+ business on the first day (net of GST), the film beat the record of the previous film in the franchise (Avengers: Infinity War) by a wide 60% margin. Not only that, it beat the biggest Hindi opener till date too, surpassing the opening-day collections of Thugs Of Hindostan, without having the benefit of a huge nationwide holiday like the Aamir Khan film.

     

    Avengers: Endgame is on course to do 375-400 Cr business in India, which will beat the lifetime box office record held by Avengers: Infinity War by about 150 Cr. Normally, such records are broken after a gap of a few years, because ticket rates go up and new multiplexes open up, giving films a wider number to achieve on the same demand. But that’s not the case in the Avengers example. The market scenario is largely similar to last year, barring a reduction in GST on movie tickets. A steep 150-Cr growth in just 12 months clearly highlights the growing equity and stature of brand Marvel in India.

     

    If one was to do a list of the most powerful media brands in India, there’s very high chance that Marvel will top it. In a country where the language barrier itself limits the reach of International content, how the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has managed to penetrate itself, through not just metros or mini-metros but the smallest of towns, is a testimony of what genuine movie craze can be. The language accessibility helps, and the dubbed versions have contributed more than 40% of the box office of Avengers: Endgame. But even with that, the mainstream, mass status MCU has acquired in India, one film after the other, is an achievement to marvel at.

     

    This genuine movie craze is about a deep and organic connect built with the characters in MCU. There are films like Thugs Of Hindostan, and the various Salman Khan films, where the lead star has massive appeal, and if you prop up the promotions leading up to the release, you build the requisite “hype” and the film opens well, and thereafter, the content takes over to decide how long its legs are.

     

    But there’s a difference between “hype” and “craze”. MCU films, especially the bigger ones, are success stories based on craze, not hype. As was Bahubali 2. But almost every other film that’s big-ticket is a hype product. Hype doesn’t lead to genuine craze. It propels audience to visit the theatre, often because it’s the in-thing to do, and one doesn’t want to miss out on riding the hype wave. It’s an inorganic, marketing-driven way of getting a film to open well. More like a consumer push.

     

    But when there’s genuine craze, the hype builds organically on its own. Avengers: Endgame was being marketed by crazy fans in digital media and the real, offline world. The much-written about late night and early morning shows on the opening day could have been a marketing ploy by another film, but in this case, it was a certification of the craze that existed. A consumer pull that’s so strong that the film belongs to its audience even before they have seen it.

     

    We are in a push marketing era in general. Bombarded with messaging across online and traditional media, consumption of content and brands is often a function of one brand outshouting the other. In such a marketing climate, Avengers: Endgame is a rare exception that stands out. Can anything Indian, on TV or in films, match up to this level of craze anytime soon?

     

     

  • Utterly Fifaly Russilicious!

     

    By A Correspondent [updated]

     

    There are few better ways to chronicle the just-concluded FIFA World Cup than the Amul topicals. We bring you all the ads released for the Russian edition. Perhaps every edition of the World Cup sees the creators of the Amul ad at Mumbai-based da Cunha Advertising see their creative juices flowing better than ever before.

     

    We still fondly remember the ‘Maradonatohaisa, butter hona toh Amul hona’ from 1989, though couldn’t locate the image for the 1982 super-ad ‘Pau lo roz hi’ on Paolo Rossi.

     

    There have been as many as 13 ads released just in the duration of the FIFA World Cup 2018 in Russia, with, we are sure a few more could follow. For instance, how about one on the Croatian president who, like the team, won our heart.

     

    We will update this story when there’s more. Meanwhile, here’s the collection. Enjoy.